Page 10 of 10

Re: Magic Skill Icons

Posted: 31 May 2008, 15:14
by Black Don
feline monstrosity wrote:I actually prefer Othello's version. It's more "iconic" in that it's simpler and more instantly recognisable as lightning. I do think that it could lose the black outline around the lightning bolt though.
First Othello did both icons. Now that we have cleared that up I would like to ask this. What is it about the first Icon that is not "Iconic"? If it is not instantly recognizable what the heck did you think it was at first? I think people are starting to nit-pick this death. The original was fine I think we are starting to over think this to much.

Re: Magic Skill Icons

Posted: 31 May 2008, 15:42
by Rotonen
Just ignore the nitpickery alongside with most of the commentary and present a complete set to which the key people can either give a stamp of approval or eternal damnation.

Re: Magic Skill Icons

Posted: 01 Jun 2008, 14:57
by feline monstrosity
Black Don wrote:First Othello did both icons.
*Ahem* My mistake. :oops:
The point I was trying to make was the simpler the icons are the better. But point taken about nitpicking, it appears I'm a minority anyway.