The Mana World Forums

I have created 2 simple icons for items just to get my feet wet. Any comments are appreciated. If, by some miracle, these are suitable for use, they are given freely to the project.

Are those really yours? Because those come from a very strange domain name.

Of course they are mine. I wanted comments on my art, not my domain name.

They look nice but they do not fit the other icons IMO.

Ah, was just checking after ASL tried to say a runescape hat was his. I do think they look very good, but they are a bit too photorealistic.

Nice but definitely not TMW style.

Too many color shades and too much anti aliasing.

They seem a bit blurry, try giving them a bit more contrast and sharp edges

Too clinically 3D. On the chalice, it's almost like a downscaled photo.