Some feedback for contributors
Posted: 24 Apr 2010, 15:54
I am seeing a recurring theme in many development forums. It is nice to see 3 pages worth of posts in a thread in order to perfect the game.
But...
The amount of post repetition (within threads) is beyond ridiculous.
One cause?
Many people are not reading prior posts before making their comments. And, I'm sorry, but "many" is even an understatement.
It seems to me that critics are scrolling down until they see a picture, then scrolling down to the reply button without doing any reading. The result is an entire page of critique with maybe 3 posts of substance.
I'll even bet the violators will read this post and think, "I agree, damn them!" Without considering themselves as part of the problem.
The solution
Let's ALL -- EVERYONE -- make sure that we are reading (and comprehending) to ensure that feedback is worth while.
STOP HERE FOR PEOPLE WHO DON'T LIKE TO READ LONGER POSTS
-------
This was sparked when I noticed in Stava/bcs playerset thread that my immediate reply to Stava's latest sample (where I made 3 points) had now had 2 of the points repeated; one each by two different people, and one of the points even repeated a third time by another person.
But we all know that this wasn't the first time, and that this conversation has happened amidst other topics, but now I've decided to make an official thread (and for the sake of hypocrisy, I didn't even bother to see if a similar thread has existed before).
I'm not even going to bother with the nature of thread repetition, I've accepted the phenomenon as part of "the nature of the beast".
Thanks for reading!
But...
The amount of post repetition (within threads) is beyond ridiculous.
One cause?
Many people are not reading prior posts before making their comments. And, I'm sorry, but "many" is even an understatement.
It seems to me that critics are scrolling down until they see a picture, then scrolling down to the reply button without doing any reading. The result is an entire page of critique with maybe 3 posts of substance.
I'll even bet the violators will read this post and think, "I agree, damn them!" Without considering themselves as part of the problem.
The solution
Let's ALL -- EVERYONE -- make sure that we are reading (and comprehending) to ensure that feedback is worth while.
STOP HERE FOR PEOPLE WHO DON'T LIKE TO READ LONGER POSTS
-------
This was sparked when I noticed in Stava/bcs playerset thread that my immediate reply to Stava's latest sample (where I made 3 points) had now had 2 of the points repeated; one each by two different people, and one of the points even repeated a third time by another person.
But we all know that this wasn't the first time, and that this conversation has happened amidst other topics, but now I've decided to make an official thread (and for the sake of hypocrisy, I didn't even bother to see if a similar thread has existed before).
I'm not even going to bother with the nature of thread repetition, I've accepted the phenomenon as part of "the nature of the beast".
Thanks for reading!