Page 1 of 1

Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 25 Apr 2010, 14:29
by Alons
I think he would make a nice GM.

He is reasonable and well-balanced, and I think he would act fairly, with no doubt to listen and to enforce the rules when necessary.

So at least, allow him to prove himself as a good GM.

NOTE: I would appreciate people who doesnt know what to vote to make and effort and try at least to talk with him before voting. That will make you at least vote "yes" or "no" clearly.

Regards,

Alons.

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 25 Apr 2010, 16:18
by snoopy
Yeah nice man for Gm ,but i think he sell him player. :o :o :shock: :shock:

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 25 Apr 2010, 16:36
by Alons
He was about to sell it, but finally he didn't and he will continue on.

Regards,

Alons.

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 25 Apr 2010, 17:23
by dayve
I voted no because i seldom see him play and do see him sit in town AFK alot. We dont need another AFK GM.

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 28 Apr 2010, 18:40
by Alons
I want to thank Lord of the Flies and dayve for showing your reasons to vote for no.

Have fun! See you in game =).

Regards,

Alons.

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 14:10
by azrael
I voted no, because he seems to nuke people alot and we dont need a gm who nukes people when their not even talking to him

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 16:07
by snoopy
azrael wrote:I voted no, because he seems to nuke people alot and we dont need a gm who nukes people when their not even talking to him
oO really he nuke player,he dont nuke me ever i think,he's nice. :D

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 29 Apr 2010, 17:10
by Cotillion
Alons wrote:I think he would make a nice GM.

He is reasonable and well-balanced, and I think he would act fairly, with no doubt to listen and to enforce the rules when necessary.
Thank you Al0nS. I appreciate the nomination and the vote of support. I have always tried to be reasonable and honest in my time in TMW, it is nice to see that reflected in your nomination of me for GM.
snoopy wrote:Yeah nice man for Gm ,but i think he sell him player. :o :o :shock: :shock:
Still here. Even with the auction, I never planned on leaving TMW. I have played numerous ALTs over the years, and despite deleting all of Cotillion Shadow's (Thank you a gain DEV's for the Item Bank), I still have one or two I play from time to time. I was never leaving TMW. Sorry if there was any confusion.

dayve wrote:I voted no because i seldom see him play and do see him sit in town AFK alot. We dont need another AFK GM.
dayve. You are absolutely right. I do not "play" as much as I used to, although I am still leveling, reached 91 this week. I have turned 100% mage, and have been enjoying it very much. But as mage, I don't spend time in the GY as many others do. You will mostly see me up North killing skulls, or still hunting the elusive Four Leaf Clover. When I am not doing that, I will run around some newbie lands, watch the market for good deals, or play my own version of Santa. (If you have ever found slimes dropping odds and ends, you can thank Santa).

Lord of the Flies wrote:Voted no for a couple reason and not simply because I do not like him.

The fact he recently was going to sell his account and quit the game tells me he can't be trusted. And by me saying can't be trusted I mean if he gets the job who knows if he will be around from one day to the next. I'm going to vote for someone I think is going to be in it for the long haul. We already have 2 gms that just seem to show up when they feel like it ban a couple people and vanish again.

Second reason he comes across as a bit arrogant. Which usually worsens when given a lil' power. He has abuser written all over him.
Lord of the Flies. I am sorry you do not like me. I have never had much dealings with you, but don't recall any time we had bad dealings with one another. Your point on me auctioning Cotillion I hope I answered above. But let me state once again, I had no intentions to stop playing TMW. I have played many online games, but none has kept me entertained as much as TMW. I am here to stay.

azrael wrote:I voted no, because he seems to nuke people alot and we dont need a gm who nukes people when their not even talking to him
azrael. Nuke is a wonderful tool. It is session only, so next time I restart my client, everyone is visible again. So I don't have to put people off and on ignore. If there is a debate (aka chat spam), topic I am not interested in, spammers, merchants (if I am not in the mood to buy or sell), I will utilize the wonderful feature of Nuke. That way I can focus on the conversations I am interested in, and enjoy the game as much as I want to. Ignore and Nuke are way underutilized by the community IMO. I wouldn't continue to use nuke as I do today if I were to become a GM. I hope you understand the rationalization there.
snoopy wrote:oO really he nuke player,he dont nuke me ever i think,he's nice. :D
Thanks snoopy. I don't believe you have ever ended up on nuke.


For those of you still undecided, you can get more information about my thoughts as GM under "Questionary for people who want to be GMs" http://forums.themanaworld.org/viewtopi ... 1&start=30

Thank you again for the nomination.

-Cotillion

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 17:02
by Cotillion
MrWho wrote:I voted NO because Cotillion does not wish to become a GM, stop opening topics for him.
MrWho, if I make it past the vote, and TMW thinks I would make a good GM, I would take it and honer the responsibility.

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 30 Apr 2010, 22:34
by enchilado
Also, AFAIK GMs aren't allowed to put people on Ignore or Nuke them, so it doesn't matter how much he does it at present. YES from me.

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 01 May 2010, 20:38
by Matt
I voted "Yes" cause I don't care.

(Oh, my vote resulted into 50/50, nice)

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 07 May 2010, 13:50
by baseballboy
I will vote yes because I have known Cotillion for about a year now and as long as I've known him he has always been very nice, responsible, and loyal. He is a great person to talk to. Very friendly and over all a very great guy.

So like I said I will vote yes :)


<!-- BBB -->

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 01 Nov 2010, 18:10
by Big Crunch
Cotillion does not wish to be GM

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 01 Nov 2010, 18:15
by Dude
Big Crunch wrote:Cotillion does not wish to be GM
Ok, this is why I vote yes for people....

Re: Should Cotillion be a GM?

Posted: 01 Nov 2010, 19:01
by Platyna
Closing as requested.

Regards.