The Mana World Forums

Ok I thought about this vote a bit longer.
XJ_RAY is a very good ingame friend for me and alone for that I would like to cast a yes BUT as I said there are few things and maybe Ray can help clarify those, because those things are the things that would make me vote "no".

Just a short time ago, may it be two or three weeks you told people you will quit this game and you started giving things away. You really showed that you don't care about your things anymore which is a very strong indicator that showed that you are serious.
So how can I know that you are not only staying in this game because a gm poll got opened for you. How can I know that you stay for the game itself, for the people, etc?

Second thing, you told me you would enforce the rules the same way on everyone, no favourites. You made very clear that you would even kick a friend because you make no difference.
If I think a bit farther (correctly spelled?) it sounds hard for me. It sounds like you'd just be coming ingame with a thought like "i am here to do my gm job". Which I would not only find sad but also a little scary.

cu ingame
Leela

Ok, so be it. I vote no. If you can not take a little criticism with out calling people stupid, you would never be able to handle being a gm.

I said I did not vote and was waiting for your response, instead of taking the adult way out and replying in a respectful manner, you took your natural way out. A gm can not name calls and accuse because someone disagrees with him/her. They just can not do it.

We have seen your true character here. It is nice to know we got it out in public before we did something we would regret.

lol i so had to laugh right now.
What is this?
xj_ray just made clear that basing a vote on something that has nothing to do with the player the vote is about, is not exactly smart. he also explained his way of playing and by that made clear how he gathered his gp and items. that is unprofessional?

i voted yes by now - exactly because of the reaction he showed here. Dealing with trolls in a professional way is a good thing.
Wish you the best, mate.

.

xj_ray wrote: Thanks to those of you that didn't judge me on another players stupidity.

XJ-Ray [/b]

You called her stupid, not a good move. Vote is no. The only thing you did in your post was attack, when you should have defended. Not smart.

thedarkfinder wrote:

xj_ray wrote: Thanks to those of you that didn't judge me on another players stupidity.

XJ-Ray [/b]

You called her stupid, not a good move. Vote is no. The only thing you did in your post was attack, when you should have defended. Not smart.

XJ =>

thedarkfinder wrote:

xj_ray wrote: Thanks to those of you that didn't judge me on another players stupidity.

XJ-Ray [/b]

You called her stupid, not a good move. Vote is no. The only thing you did in your post was attack, when you should have defended. Not smart.

XJ_RAY probably have meant Davius & not DarkWater
Guys, DarkWater is an experienced player here in tmw. I think she knows what she's doing. I wouldnt interfere her unless i see serious reason to tackle her.

I voted no, (at least you get a comment from a no vote)
dont hate on my choice.


Regards,

thedarkfinder wrote:The only thing you did in your post was attack, when you should have defended. Not smart.

where was it an attack and why should he defend? There was nothing to defend. DarkWater was talking about stuff that does not count here and XJ_RAY answered it.
Look Davius just started the poll, the topic is not about Davius, it is about XJ_RAY
XJ_RAY has GP and items - big deal? everyone has gp and items. some more some less. I have like 1,5 million gp and several rares. Wanna discuss here too?
He played for what he had but even that, is not a matter of this discussion!

A matter of this thread is:
Will he be fair?
How will he judge?
When will he be online?
Is his English good enough? (well he is native speaker)
Does he have any experience in GMing/Moderating/being Admin?
Why would he like to be GM? And: Would he like that at all?

@Admin: Please check for sockpuppeting in the votes. I have the feeling there could be some sockpuppeting going on (even with the new minimum of posting to vote)

Leela wrote:

thedarkfinder wrote:The only thing you did in your post was attack, when you should have defended. Not smart.

where was it an attack and why should he defend? There was nothing to defend. DarkWater was talking about stuff that does not count here and XJ_RAY answered it.
Look Davius just started the poll, the topic is not about Davius, it is about XJ_RAY
XJ_RAY has GP and items - big deal? everyone has gp and items. some more some less. I have like 1,5 million gp and several rares. Wanna discuss here too?
He played for what he had but even that, is not a matter of this discussion!

A matter of this thread is:
Will he be fair?
How will he judge?
When will he be online?
Is his English good enough? (well he is native speaker)
Does he have any experience in GMing/Moderating/being Admin?
Why would he like to be GM? And: Would he like that at all?

@Admin: Please check for sockpuppeting in the votes. I have the feeling there could be some sockpuppeting going on (even with the new minimum of posting to vote)

No Leela you are wrong, dark water&co surely said at her manafriend to vote no for him... that do me vomit
Leave her alone Leelala and continue to help XJ to be a GM without take care of her.

i vote for axalix!

Firstly - I really don't think who nominated him should be considered at all. It's a matter of who was the first to do so, and that can be someone "undesirable" for anyone. If some annoying spammer had nominated Tiana, does this mean she would have been voted against based on that? I hope not.


Second - comments like this are supremely irritating (no offense iceslice! ). "Guys, DarkWater is an experienced player here in tmw. I think she knows what she's doing. I wouldnt interfere her unless i see serious reason to tackle her."

Understand, I mean no offense to DW or anybody at all in saying this. But come on - I don't care who somebody is, what level they are, or how respected they are/think they might be... But if you'll avoid doing something you'd normally do, because of who someone is... in a GAME... that is pretty damn silly to me. So, walk on eggshells around certain people all you wish, but come on - I don't care if you're Bill Gates in real life, if you're a jerk I'll tell you so.

Random Note: Regarding the whole Bent Needles thing, and exploiting the system... I myself bought 100 off TradeBot, and suspect I know who got them all and put them up lol. It wasn't XJ_RAY. Chances are most of the game's Needles came from the same person, as he camped the haystack for... well, the entire time the quest was out. Either way... If a quest allows some exploit, why should somebody not be considered for GM because of it? I bet at least one GM used the exploit where you could do the Easter quest at level 1 to get more rabbit ears.

It's just kind of saddening that picking a GM comes down to "do I like him/her or not?" I don't think we need to adore said person, and we're picking a rule enforcer, not a new friend. So, feel free to base your vote on whether you and your friends like this candidate, but know that this is exactly what is wrong with the voting system in general. (Again, not directing this to anyone particular, more in general.)