Page 1 of 1

The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 12 Dec 2020, 13:20
by Cage

The game used to get a lot of new players from this site, but it seems like the last update was made in 2014, would it be possible to update it here too ?

mana.JPG
mana.JPG (59.19 KiB) Viewed 3383 times

https://sourceforge.net/projects/themanaworld/


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 12 Dec 2020, 13:31
by WildX

Is Sourceforge still relevant? It seems to have been a delibarate choice to abandon it (https://sourceforge.net/p/themanaworld/news/) as apparently the 2012 and 2014 teams didn't find it useful. If revived, it would only be for crossposting news. I don't know if it will get enough traffic to justify the effort though.

I don't have access to it but I believe Jesusalva recently mentioned it among the things we have login details for in the keyring.


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 12 Dec 2020, 14:14
by Cage

Their algorithm probably ignored it because it doesn´t get updated


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 12 Dec 2020, 16:30
by jesusalva
WildX wrote: 12 Dec 2020, 13:31

Is Sourceforge still relevant? It seems to have been a delibarate choice to abandon it (https://sourceforge.net/p/themanaworld/news/) as apparently the 2012 and 2014 teams didn't find it useful. If revived, it would only be for crossposting news. I don't know if it will get enough traffic to justify the effort though.

I don't have access to it but I believe Jesusalva recently mentioned it among the things we have login details for in the keyring.

Yes we have the login details for user "themanaworld".
But several projects moved away from SourceForge completely.

In fact, even FreedroidRPG and SuperTux (to name a few events) moved away from SF, and all moved away around 2014, so it is not a "TMW-thing". I guess something must have happened similar to when M$ bought Github and people moved to Gitlab, so I suggest more investigation. "It is not useful" doesn't seems to be the motif, after all.


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 12 Dec 2020, 17:29
by EJlol

Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 12 Dec 2020, 17:35
by Livio

From my point of view TMW managed to have a good amount of players even without registering the project on any mainstream platform possible. As such effort will probably take away time from development it will be good only to attract people to play an old server and to give up a new, incomplete one.
And honestly, I wont take any TMW fresh forum accounts with few post into consideration too much since many of them proved to be source of complaints, useless drama and didn't lasted for long in game.


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 13 Dec 2020, 08:29
by Cage
Livio wrote: 12 Dec 2020, 17:35

From my point of view TMW managed to have a good amount of players even without registering the project on any mainstream platform possible. As such effort will probably take away time from development it will be good only to attract people to play an old server and to give up a new, incomplete one.
And honestly, I wont take any TMW fresh forum accounts with few post into consideration too much since many of them proved to be source of complaints, useless drama and didn't lasted for long in game.

It was a mere suggestion Livio, I'm not trying to cause any drama :lol: .
I used to download the game from Sourceforge, I actually discovered it on that website and it felt weird when I saw that it was last updated on 2014, I'm sorry if this post caused any problem :oops: .


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 13 Dec 2020, 13:59
by Hocus Pocus Fidibus
Cage wrote: 13 Dec 2020, 08:29

I used to download the game from Sourceforge, I actually discovered it on that website and it felt weird when I saw that it was last updated on 2014, I'm sorry if this post caused any problem :oops: .

That is a good point. Maybe it would be better to remove it from sf completely so people do not think it is an abandoned project when looking there.


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 13 Dec 2020, 14:01
by WildX
Livio wrote: 12 Dec 2020, 17:35

And honestly, I wont take any TMW fresh forum accounts with few post into consideration too much since many of them proved to be source of complaints, useless drama and didn't lasted for long in game.

This is a very effective way to discourage new users and make these forum useless in the long run. Useless complaints, stupidity and trolling can (and often do) come from long time players and forum users.

All opinions are welcome. If your opinions are stupid we will be able to filter them out anyway :wink:


Re: The Mana World on Sourceforge should be updated

Posted: 13 Dec 2020, 15:51
by Hello=)

I'd say SourceForge been nasty enough to make it into my adblocker. So I get BIG RED WARNING before trying to visit it as it's "malvertising site".

This said, SF still provides some extra visibility - and also apparently gave up malvertising habits after mentioned scandal. So if someone can do it, I think it would benefit project as whole, players community and so on.

p.s. and btw, 5 stars isn't exactly bad rating, isn't it? :P