Page 1 of 1

----

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 00:51
by Keio
So I can't delete my own post, that's a weird rule.

Please some admin delete it.

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 00:54
by Crush
There are still Pokemon fans around there? I thought kids these days were through with Pokemon and already behind the next big fad.

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 00:55
by Simeon
Spam really.

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 01:03
by Keio
Oh well... ok, I didn't mean to spam.. but this is OffTopic right?

Where is the delete button?

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 01:06
by Simeon
Well it's okay I guess but trying to recruit developers on the forums of another MMORPG project is a bit... odd ;)

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 01:19
by Crush
Is it at least open source?

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 01:33
by Keio
Crush wrote:There are still Pokemon fans around there? I thought kids these days were through with Pokemon and already behind the next big fad.
well, you are right.. Pokemon is just a game with silly monsters you have to beat.... Ohh wait o_O

It can't be open source because Nintendo would sue them. ( I think.. not really sure)

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 02:26
by Dave
Crush wrote:There are still Pokemon fans around there? I thought kids these days were through with Pokemon and already behind the next big fad.
Sure kids still like Pokemon.. they're just 20 years old now. :o

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 13:14
by Simeon
Keio wrote:
Crush wrote:There are still Pokemon fans around there? I thought kids these days were through with Pokemon and already behind the next big fad.
well, you are right.. Pokemon is just a game with silly monsters you have to beat.... Ohh wait o_O

It can't be open source because Nintendo would sue them. ( I think.. not really sure)
Isn't it a problem anyway, regardless of the license, because you're using the Pokemon intellectual property?

It would not be allowed to create an (open-source) Zelda game or a game featuring any of the other Nintendo characters, simply because they're copyrighted.

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 13:55
by Dave
Who's making an open-source Zelda game? Somebody destroy this junk-thread.

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 14:51
by Falcata
Simeon wrote:
Keio wrote:
Crush wrote:There are still Pokemon fans around there? I thought kids these days were through with Pokemon and already behind the next big fad.
well, you are right.. Pokemon is just a game with silly monsters you have to beat.... Ohh wait o_O

It can't be open source because Nintendo would sue them. ( I think.. not really sure)
Isn't it a problem anyway, regardless of the license, because you're using the Pokemon intellectual property?

It would not be allowed to create an (open-source) Zelda game or a game featuring any of the other Nintendo characters, simply because they're copyrighted.
You wouldn't be able to create a closed-source game either. Unless you have permission, which is unlikely. If doing so, you would have to be very careful, or at least come up with a very good Fair Use defense.

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 14:58
by Simeon
Falcata wrote:You wouldn't be able to create a closed-source game either. Unless you have permission, which is unlikely. If doing so, you would have to be very careful, or at least come up with a very good Fair Use defense.
Yes, it applies to closed-source as well of course - I don't think fair use covers such significant use of the intellectual property of others; after all, a lot of the game depends on that artwork.

Posted: 09 Feb 2008, 15:10
by Falcata
It really depends on the manner in which it is used, but the defense will usually fail in these cases. Parodies, however, usually succeed in the fair use defense. It also depends a lot on copyright laws, which are different in each country.

Posted: 10 Feb 2008, 23:30
by bankai
dabe wrote:
Crush wrote:There are still Pokemon fans around there? I thought kids these days were through with Pokemon and already behind the next big fad.
Sure kids still like Pokemon.. they're just 20 years old now. :o
sure me and mai cousin break out the old g1 pokemon versions and beat eachother up