The Mana World Forums

Similar idea to tombstone, wait wait, let me explain

When a person dies, their sprite switches to a Ghost sprite.

When a Ghost, the player has access to walk around in a ghost sprite, or Return to nearest town.

This will also give the person a sprite, so others can revive them.

so... ill post a few pics ina sec

Here it is! steps are in 3
Step 1: Normal
Step 2: Died
Step 3: Ghost!



Ofcourse the sprites WILL be different, just messing around with them

This also lets people turn into Stalkers O>O AND allows people to follow team mates for long periods of time, waiting for them to find a ressurection item

BUT! there is a loophole to this!, When a person is dead... he can walk right?, well that would cause alot of cheating... So heres my play, when a player turns into a ghost, the player can only walk INSIDE the map her died on !!, so ONLY on the map he died on, no further. So we can make it so that if the player tries going into a warp portal or door or anyhting, it rejects him!

Or no further than a certain radius away from your body.

i guess that works too, but wouldnt that put alot of stress on the server?

Or would that be client side?

Why having a walking ghost would cause cheating?

i can only name 1 way of cheating...
Safety in travels... A person can die, then go on a journey as a Ghost, then get revived at the destination he wanted to go, so lets say the person wants to go passed a tough dungeon, he would kill himself, then go thru the dungeon... After look for a ressurection.

So its sorta cheating...

Well I think the aim of going into a dungeon is to reach the end where you can find treasures and what else, obiouvsly you can't revive there.
Wait maybe you're right because one of your friends can revive you there...
Well I think we have to find a nice solution, because I like the ghosts idea, but I don't like that much the idea that your soul can't go far from your body.

Why overdoing it? Just leave the corpse there and let the player decide if he will wait for resurrection or just respawn ("Press this button if you want to return to the town").

I see no gain by letting him wonder as a ghost in the map he died on. He can use the chat to request help anyway.

How about some permanent negative effects after a certain number of deaths? For example your max HP would be lower after 10 deaths and really minimal after 100. It could be exploited to a certain degree, but.. (And also, penalties for the time you've spent dead. That should remove the travelling dilemma.)

The "range from the body" concept is interesting, we could even have an astral projection skill which adds to that range and reduces the effects (we could have areas in which you cannot get unless your party has an astral projector). I'm just bouncing ideas here.

How about when a player dies they turn into a ghost and their body is still on the ground. So the ghost can move around but the body just lies there where the player died. So when someone comes to revive the player they have to revive the BODY not the ghost.

as, I think Modanung, said it would be quite fair if the ghost would loose experience points while he is dead

hmm

maybe something like that: ?

Step 1: Normal
- Player is alive

Step 2: Dead
- Dead notification window should give options -> 1=wait (stay dead), 2=Ghost, 3=Respawn
- Player can't move but can be revived by other players (time unlimited)

Step 3: Ghost
- While being a ghost the spiritual energy of the player (INT, MP or something) will decrease.
- Ghosts can only move around as long as they have spiritual energy.
- Ghosts can't be revived by other players (because "ghosts" are invisible )
- Ghosts can revive themselves at shrines to cut down long walks?

Step 4: Rebirth
- If the player choose that option or spiritual energy reaches zero -> Respawn at last town -> Step 1

treo wrote:as, I think Modanung, said it would be quite fair if the ghost would loose experience points while he is dead

Did I say that?

Kinetic wrote:How about when a player dies they turn into a ghost and their body is still on the ground. So the ghost can move around but the body just lies there where the player died. So when someone comes to revive the player they have to revive the BODY not the ghost.

Just my words

I like Peace makers idea

It kills the loophole, unless theres a shrine somewhere close by right?

Pajarico wrote:

Kinetic wrote:How about when a player dies they turn into a ghost and their body is still on the ground. So the ghost can move around but the body just lies there where the player died. So when someone comes to revive the player they have to revive the BODY not the ghost.

Just my words :wink:

Yes, I would prefer this idea as well. Still when we do this I'm not sure what's the whole point of this ghost thing though. I know they have a ghost in WoW but there it somehow spawns from the graveyard and has to walk towards the dead body, just saying it doesn't make sense at all.

In TomeNET when you die you become a ghost and you have to be resurrected either in town or by another player. A ghost can't carry or use any items, and can fight but is a lot weaker than when you were alive, also the ghost can go through walls and ceilings. Oh and when your ghost dies, you lose your character. Also normally, a player can only die 3 times.

I think going with TomeNET way has too many problems though, and maybe we should just leave out the ghost concept and either respawn or wait for resurrection. We could force respawn when your spiritual energy has drained.