The Mana World Forums

GM Review Re: [BAN] MItsu

rodrigo14 wrote:

Ðamis™ wrote:There is none, and this is not a discussion forum. Remember that.

~Damis

I think ban for botting GM need post screenshot I'm wrong?

It is not a necessity for GMs to report screenshots, but without screenshots many players feel uncomfortable with a GM's decision, as in this case. I prefer to see screenshots for bans as well.

Skull_Master's ban also had no screenshot.

You should be able to trust an administrator/Game master/any other type of staff.

@Goku Check the "Signature Fix-Up" Topic.

I prefer to remain skeptical Damis. GMs have earned trust to gain their position, but that doesn't mean they stopped being human. This isn't an attempt at hostility with the GMs or to create a lack of "trust". This is a review of a ban without a screenshot where players can give opinions and perhaps our feedback can help the GMs. I don't think anyone has been maliciously banned from the game, if that means anything to you.

Also, because we (players) can't comment in the Court House, these types of threads are welcome here so players can discuss anything in the Court House without interference.

Katze wrote:We don't need to provide screenshots. They are just a nice extra - nothing more. They don't prove anything

As Katze said, the GM's shouldn't have to provide screenshots, they should be well trusted.

Damis, unlike you, I am not an unthinking automaton. I'm done with you.

Alright, be gone.

Screenshots can be faked anyways.

For the GM's own bot reports? That would be both sad and interesting. I still prefer the potential of a big fix over no picture. A player banned with a fixed picture would probably throw a stink.

I also prefere to be able to provide screenshots.
Yet, there are cases in which I can't do that out of stupid reasons like a different keyboard for example.

Skull_Master and Mitsu were standing at the same spot botting and they are one person. That meant they came into the same situation of me not being familiar with a keyboard.

Next time I'll know where the key is.

Thank you Katze

it seems to me that, since the special isolation room is used (as MK nearly always do it), they cannot be any way to discuss a ban for botting no ?

and what if you say to people that when you get afk you just have to sit by the side instead of being still on the spot ?

Regards

We spawn monsters on the botcheck map and often also elsewhere. So we see if someone is just standing there or actually botting. I don't see the need to tell people to sit down when they're away for that reason.

And people can always prevent being banned by reacting in any way within the set time limit. No matter where they are.

So you wouldn't get banned for just standing in a pile of people botting? Or attacking normally?

and what if you are not interested in the drops ? joke

i know perfectley honest people not botting that don't take any of the dropped items... and just take the xp

if you don't show up they won't moove