chipchip on mauve herbs

[bekka]

Hi there


according to the wiki the chipchip-spell works on herbs. It works fine on Gamboge, Alzarin and Cobalt.

But I recently tried on Mauve Herbs and not even got a drop by using chipchip on them.

Does someone know why?




regards, bekka

[o11c]

maybe someone had already used #chipchip on that particular plant within the last 10 minutes?

[bekka]

Might be, but I am vry sure I was alone on the map and tried for over an hour and nothing.

[melkior]

I'm seeing the same thing happening, even on newly spawned Mauve Plants.

Can someone else give it a go and report results?

[Jenalya]

Hm, looking at the magic code, there isn't any difference between the calls for the herbs:
https://github.com/themanaworld/tmwa-se ... plate#L827

I just did some brief testing, and on the testserver I didn't get anything from doing chipchip on mauve herbs and mouboos. o11c, could your changes on the testserver's code affect that?
On the mainserver, I got something from a mouboo, and then tried on herbs, but was quickly out of magic. Maybe some more people could try it out, and report back here?

[melkior]

Three different chars so far, an no Mauve Herbs via #chipchip.

Could someone spawn some on the botcheck or something so we can test properly?

[o11c]

I just did some brief testing, and on the testserver I didn't get anything from doing chipchip on mauve herbs and mouboos. o11c, could your changes on the testserver's code affect that?

Shouldn't be, though I *did* change the (unused) numbers in the SC_SHEARED arguments.

Note that the drops are dependent on your magic skill - if spellpower is less than 300 you don't have any chance at all. Spellpower is matk1 + 10 * (number of levels in general magic + number of levels in the school of magic) - so usually 40 more.
If spellpower is over 1000, the results might not be well-defined.

[o11c]

Jenalya: make sure the name of the spawns in _mob.txt matches both the name in mob_db.txt and the name in magic.conf

I see a lot of variation in the monster| lines.

[Nard]

I can chipchip mauves and Mouboos with no problem on main server ( and get drops).

[o11c]

I can chipchip mauves

I expect that it depends on what map you're on.

[Nard]

I tried 007-1, 010-1, 016-1
edit: also 008-1 now (all successful)

Question: result of chichip can depend on map ???

[tsukinokage]

Question: result of chichip can depend on map ???

Yes, it depends on maps. Actually, it depends on the name of the spawn area object of the map.
Long ago, I submit a commit and fixed the problem of #chipchip not working on the newly added maps for mouboos because of typo in the spawn area name. That commit was accepted, but my suggestion in the pull request about changing the server code so that it won't depend on the name of the spawn area(which I think is a really bad idea, since we can use any string in the spawn area name) is just ignored.

So, I suggest change the server code again. And I believe you only need to change one line of code in the server repo.

[o11c]

The problem with trying to change one line of server code is that it involves changing at least a thousand other lines to prevent anything from breaking.

[Nard]

Question: result of chichip can depend on map ???

Yes, it depends on maps. Actually, it depends on the name of the spawn area object of the map.
Long ago, I submit a commit and fixed the problem of #chipchip not working on the newly added maps for mouboos because of typo in the spawn area name. That commit was accepted, but my suggestion in the pull request about changing the server code so that it won't depend on the name of the spawn area(which I think is a really bad idea, since we can use any string in the spawn area name) is just ignored.

So, I suggest change the server code again. And I believe you only need to change one line of code in the server repo.

I remember that now. You have a supporter: if chipchip doesn't work as it is intended to, server code has to be modified because it is a bug. I guess, as o11c, recently checked it ( http://forums.themanaworld.org/viewtopi ... 92#p131092) that he knows exactly the number of lines which are concerned.

[o11c]

I remember that now. You have a supporter: if chipchip doesn't work as it is intended to, server code has to be modified because it is a bug. I guess, as o11c, recently checked it ( http://forums.themanaworld.org/viewtopi ... 92#p131092) that he knows exactly the number of lines which are concerned.

Edit: redacted original post.

Nard, I know a lot about the server code - far more than you can glean from my forum posts.

This problem can easily be fixed in server data, not server code.